top of page

What determines employee benefits costs?

Oct 20
4 min read

Thinking about employee benefits for your growing team? The first question is usually: what will it cost?

Fair question. And the honest answer is: it depends — but not in the vague way people usually mean. It depends on three things you can actually pin down: how many people you're covering, who they are, and what you want the plan to do. Settle those three, and the price starts to make sense.

What moves the price

1. Team size. A three-person plan and a thirty-person plan are different products in practice. Larger groups spread risk more evenly, which is part of why per-person costs tend to settle as a group grows. Smaller groups feel every change more — one large claim, one older hire, one person with ongoing prescriptions can move the renewal. That isn't a reason to wait; it's a reason to design carefully at small scale, which we'll get to.

2. Demographics. Age and family makeup matter. A team of mostly twenty-somethings with no dependants will price differently from a team of forty-somethings with families — because expected usage is different. This is also why a quote for "a 10-person company" is meaningless without knowing who the ten people are. Any quote worth trusting is built on your actual group, not a generic headcount.

3. Plan design. This is the lever you control most. The same team can have very different costs depending on what's covered and how generously:

  • What's included: drug coverage, dental, vision, paramedical (physio, massage, counselling), and extras like a health spending account each add cost — and each serves a different purpose.

  • How rich the coverage is: the percentage the plan pays (say, 80% vs. 100% of eligible drug costs), annual maximums, and deductibles all move the premium.

  • Cost-sharing: whether the business pays the full premium or shares it with employees changes both the cost and how the team values the plan.

Two businesses with the same headcount can pay meaningfully different amounts and both be getting the right plan — because they designed for different goals.

What published ranges actually show

You'll find numbers online, and they're worth reading with care. Ontario broker-published ranges typically run roughly $150–$275 per employee per month; aggregator tier tables run wider, roughly $80–$350, because tier definitions vary by insurer and group size. A 2023 BC survey benchmark put the average closer to about $1,822 per employee per year — but that figure is dated, and averages hide exactly the variation this article is about.

Treat every published figure as a signpost, not a quote. Nobody can price your plan without your group, your demographics, and your design. Anyone who gives you a number before asking those questions is guessing.

Decide what the plan must achieve first

Before comparing quotes, answer one question: what do you want this plan to accomplish?

  • Attracting staff? Then the plan needs to look competitive against what candidates see elsewhere — and you need to know what "competitive" means in your market, not in general.

  • Retaining your people? Then the plan needs to cover what your actual team values. Ask them. A plan nobody uses is an expense, not a benefit.

  • Improving access to care? Then richness of coverage matters more than breadth — a plan that pays 100% of the things people actually claim beats a broad plan with thin coverage.

The goal determines the design, and the design determines the cost. Starting with quotes and working backwards usually produces a plan that's cheap in the wrong places and expensive in the ones that matter.

Benefits don't live in isolation

Here's the part most quotes leave out: a benefits plan affects business cash flow and your own financial goals at the same time. The premium comes out of the same business that funds your compensation, your corporate savings, and — eventually — your retirement income. A plan designed without that context can work against the rest of your finances.

The same thinking applies on the retirement side. Business owners face a version of this question with their own income: RRSP vs. holding company vs. an Individual Pension Plan is a three-way decision where the right answer depends on the whole picture — compensation, corporate surplus, and what you want retirement to look like — not on any one product in isolation. Benefits and retirement are separate decisions, but they're connected pieces of the same plan. That's why we look at them together instead of in isolation.

What to settle before getting quotes

  1. Who's covered — employees only, or employees plus dependants? Anyone excluded?

  2. What the plan must achieve — attract, retain, access to care, or a mix. Rank them.

  3. Your budget frame — what the business can carry monthly, and whether cost is shared with employees.

  4. What your team actually values — ask, don't guess.

  5. Your renewal reality — how the plan will be reviewed each year, so the first year's price doesn't become a surprise in year two.

Bring those five answers to the conversation and the quotes you get will be comparable, honest, and built for your business — not for a generic "10-person company" that doesn't exist.

About GenThrive Benefits: We help business owners connect the pieces — personal, business, and team finances — so each decision supports the others instead of competing with them.

Next step: If you'd like to map benefits for your team, our complimentary 20-minute Business Owner Financial Check-In is a low-key place to start.

Comments


GenThrive Benefits Logo

Get in Touch

GenThrive Benefits Inc. is based on Vancouver Island and proudly serves businesses in BC.

Disclaimer

GenThrive Benefits Inc. provides group benefits consulting, group retirement plan support, and non-securities financial planning services. Insurance-related recommendations and insurance product implementation (including life, health, disability, and participating insurance strategies) are provided only by individually licensed advisors in their personal capacities, separate from GenThrive Benefits Inc.

Information on this website is for general educational purposes and should not be considered personal financial, tax, or legal advice. GenThrive Benefits Inc. does not act as a licensed insurance agency and does not sell insurance products as a corporation.

© 2025 GenThrive Benefits Inc. | All rights reserved. |  Wildcoast Web Design

bottom of page